Holding these truths

Here’s a patriotic column for the fourth.

In confused and stressful times like these, in which the word “government” has become a curseword, it’s good to go back to the earliest moments of our founding and refresh ourselves with the basic logic of the American enterprise. In fact, our own democratic government is, in theory anyway, inspiring and comforting: one of the best things about us.

This is how we started: “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness. — That to secure these rights, Governments are instituted among Men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.”

Would these truths have seemed self-evident if this writing had not declared them to be so? In any case, I find reading this declaration to have the comfort of coming home to something fundamental in my education, in my own American life.

We hold these truths”: Meaning, in a more limited sense, “we coming up with this language, doing this instituting,” but in a broader sense, it’s “we” the people, human beings more generally in whose behalf the authors were speaking. Yes, there’s a leap of faith in a reading of this as something other than “we rich, white men”. It feels like as generous and inclusive a “we” of which these men were capable. (Of course in those pre-feminist days, “men” was generic: mankind, including women, even if for women it was a more abstract equality/inclusion which has taken a long time to find expression in laws. )

We hold these truths to be self-evident . . .” Note: not “God tell us” or even “we know” but “we hold.” A good, honest start, this recognition that in instituting a government you are building a boat under you while already afloat (that basic human condition). You’ve got to start somewhere, and we start with these cherished beliefs and values.

What a lovely, humane, reassuring start it is–to a government, to a society, to each individual life that is born into that society– this self-evident truth that all are created equal. (And, actually, if you look closely, that “all” seems to include those born elsewhere as well. It doesn’t say “all men born on this side of the ocean, within our national boundaries, north of the wall…)

Note that the truth held is that we are all born equal, among other ways, in wanting a good life. Nobody wants to be miserable.

It is often insisted that these words do not guarantee happiness, only the right to pursue it. But the implication, it seems clear, is that something’s wrong if we, if some of us, (let alone many millions) are miserable. That the proof of whether or not government has delivered the right to pursue is in the pudding.

There is nothing here of “devil take the hindmost” or “cream rising to the top.” Note that it doesn’t say we are all equally motivated to become hedge fund managers, accumulate a big net worth. It doesn’t even say you are more virtuous if you do. It does say that we are equally interested in coming up with some version of a good life.

It doesn’t talk about how big or small government should be, but it doesn’t leave room for anything but a government big enough to do what it proposes, to produce the sort of life it declares is equally the natural endowment of all.

It still seems a deeply satisfying founding and shaping idea. And an indisputably generous and liberal idea it is. Probably a lot of us still hold these truths to be self-evident. And maybe the failure to make sure our government does what it’s supposed to do is part of our bitterness now.

Trump as capitalist-in-chief

Opponents often see what they consider Trump’s ill fit for the presidency in terms of psychological sickness. Some imagine that, suffering from such dire-sounding conditions as “narcissistic personality disorder” or “attention deficit disorder” or maybe a version of Asbergers, (and what about those symptoms of dictator envy), he may not last long in the job. […]

The Ptown scene in the time of Trump

Fine late afternoon and evening in Ptown this past Saturday, reminding us that one of the great things about Wellfleet is having Ptown so close. The morning’s rain blown away, it is (at last) glorious summahtime, warm and humid, as we meander west on Commercial, checking out the scene and immersing in it at the […]


So we’ll see if Ptown makes out any better than Wellfleet in getting respect for its more-or-less identical formula business bylaw (FBB). The town’s zoning board of appeals turned down CVS’s special permit and the company’s lawyer says they will appeal. The lawyer says that the exterior of the new store will be visually unobjectionable, […]

The fallacy of “media bias” (Part 2 of 2)

The fallacy of “media bias” is playing a large role in the current national crisis. Newspapers like to claim objectivity (fairness, balance). It serves their interests to be seen as above the fray, the “paper of record.” But clearly, given the wide range of political flavors newspapers and other news sources come in, there are […]

The Fallacy of “Media bias” (1 of 2)

Widespread confusion about “media bias” is playing a large role in the current national crisis, serving the interests largely of Trump. House Speaker Ryan, explaining why fellow Republicans shouldn’t get too worked up about all the possibly impeachable offenses: “ It is obvious that there are some people out there who want to harm the […]

Voting ourselves a bigger gun

The first night of Wellfleet’s recent Town Meeting, FinCom, trying hard to curb spending, suggested cutting the proposed $101,000 budget for “legal services” in half. In the debate, one selectman pointed out that we spent about that amount just in the lalte 2016 court case trying (unsuccessfully) to prevent Cumberland Farms’ makeover of its existing […]

Cliché by the Sea

Has anyone else seen “Year By The Sea”? Just wondering if there are fellow victims out there. This is not a recommendation. Yes, it was filmed mostly in Wellfleet and there is some pretty photography of our harbor, streets and buildings, so it’s understandable that those with a Wellfleet connection will want to satisfy their […]

What was the selectmen’s real vote on the Safe Community Act?

When, on night three of Wellfleet’s Town Meeting, it came to the vote on he Safe Communities Act,the selectmen were listed as having voted 5-0 in favor. It felt uncomfortable, therefore, to have two selectmen trying to sway the vote against the measure. But without really coming out and saying so. If, as it seemed […]

Testing for effect of Eversource spraying?

Like most of those who have spoken up, including those who represent our town, I’m against Eversource’s ongoing spraying of the powerlines as their ill-chosen method of keeping the plants down. The universal condemnation, especially by those abutting the powerlines, should be enough for the company to go back to mechanical “mowing,” which certainly seemed […]