Was the Cuban revolution a failure?

The opening of the US toward Cuba seems a good moment to evaluate Castro’s 1959 revolution. The impression I get from the media and comments by even liberal friends is that it is widely considered a failure.

Those of a liberal bent give Castro credit for getting rid of the dictator and the dominance of Big Sugar. Many acknowledge the revolution’s achievements in education and medicine. But did Castro need to jail all those dissidents? And given the austerity of life for most Cubans in the last 20 years, how can the revolution be considered anything but a failure?

But failure compared to what? The previous 56 years for the island nation (Batista and predecessors)? Compared with life in the US (say, in Miami for the self-exiled exploiting class?) That wouldn’t seem fair.

It’s surprising we don’t hear attempts to answer the question by comparing Cuba with, say, Grenada, the other Caribbean island whose 1979 revolution the US managed to nip in the bud and which has presumably been basking in our approval ever since.

Apples and oranges, of course. Cuba is a much bigger island; Grenada is only the size of Martha’s Vineyard. It took a lot more—lives, time, determination—to unseat Batista than Grenada’s dictator, Gairy, and his little army of thugs called the Mongoose Gang. But there are similarities. Both revolutions started with ideal of bettering life for the great majority. Both revolutions first turned for help and support to the US, whose response in both cases was to do its best to crush both revolutions, infamously failing in the case of Cuba, but succeeding witgh tiny Grenada with the help, it is widely believed, of a CIA- engineered coup.

So: the revolution we failed to abort vs. the one we did: How has it been working for both? It would be interesting to have a detailed comparison including both economic statistics and other quality-of -life factors.
How have those Grenadians Reagan rescued from the clutches of socialist idealism been doing the last 30 -plus years?

Would Cuba have been better off if Batista had never been challenged? Would Batista-sponsored capitalism have reformed itself?

You would think we would at least be curious about the question.

Native Americans and the meaning of “we”

This is something that never occurred to me before spending time in Mexico (where we go for a few weeks to reduce the length of winter). A very big difference between north and south of the border is in the content of “we.” Mexico is a much more racially homogenized society than ours. It’s one […]

Impossible but true: a city without traffic lights

One of the most striking things about this small city of San Miguel de Allende, Mexico, is that there are no traffic lights or stop signs in the whole city. How can that be? By what we know and how we live traffic-wise in el norte, such a thing is impossible. Traffic lights and signs […]

Opiates, anti-depressants, soma

Everybody knows that opiates such as heroin are evil, life-ruining drugs, while anti-depressants such as Prozac are good drugs, gateway only to mental health and reasonable happiness for many millions. An article in the professional journal “Psychotherapy Networker” ( Mary Sykes Wylie, “Falling in Love Again,” July/aug 2014) provides an illuminating historical perspective, pointing out […]

The limits to “ protected speech”

In the wake of Charlie Hebdo we are hearing a lot about “protected speech,” the sort we congratulate ourselves on having in this and other “free, democratic” countries. (And deplore the lack of in, say, Castro’s Cuba.) The term is commonly held to apply to a wide variety of speech but to exclude the sort […]


In a world with so many big and possibly insoluble problems (cancer, climate, income inequality, religion), this seems a little thing. But it has the advantage of seeming doable, and probably has a connection to the big things. I hereby nominate junk mail reform for my short list of no-brainer improvements in the quality of […]

Hebdo:Free speech is not a damsel in distress

About the Charlie Hebdo massacre, what is to be said beyond the widespread righteous indignation over what seems to most in the West a shockingly—and tragically– out-of-proportion reaction to mere cartoons? One thing seems clear, Charlie Hebdo exposes the limits and naivete of the old saying: “Sticks and stones may break my bones but words […]

War between religion and secular culture

From all the emphasis on the Charlie Hebdo massacre as an attack on free speech, what’s getting lost is the reality of this as a battle in the contemporary war of secular culture vs. religion. From my admittedly incomplete perusal of online news sources, the magazine has it in for Christianity as well as Islam. […]

Sharing the world with temptation

Among everybody’s New Year’s resolutions is surely turning over a new leaf on the opiate epidemic. 40 years into the War on Drugs the drugs are still winning. According to recent alarming coverage in this paper, they are on the offensive here on Cape Cod. In fact the campaign we’ve been waging on this major […]

Nuclear power is dead

The most compelling argument for closing Pilgrim Nuclear Power Plant for those off us nearby and downwind is that it should never have been built there in the first place with “no escape from the Cape” (and none imaginable). Although the worst case scenario is unlikely, the consequences are so devastating and terminal, it seems […]