Local opposition to state bike path plan being ignored by leaders

Wellfleet citizens have been in a struggle with the state over a controversial plan to extend the existing Rail Trail to an already congested stretch of Route 6. The plan has been widely opposed by local citizens as dangerous as well as inconsistent with the idea of a scenic and peaceful bike trail.

So it was a surprise to read our Town Administrator’s take on the situation in an email that’s been circulating.

In this email–”forwarded to the zoning board” according to a member of that board– the TA reports on a recent meeting with the state and others and talks about how well the state’s efforts to extend the Rail Trail to Route 6 are going, including sidewalks and bike lanes along the highway and a certain distance down Main St. toward downtown. He sums up: “I think we are making good progress on the design for the area based on public input.”

I had to read that twice: Progress? Work on extending the bike path to Route 6 is progress? Based on public input? Really?

In the past several months there have been several well-publicized expressions of public input, all unambiguously against the state’s plan. A well-attended public hearing was almost unanimously against extended the bike path to Route 6. Town meeting in April with a near-unanimous vote passed a resolution against the idea. And, according to former Select Board member Dale Donovan, an anti-extension petition signed by 1100 people is being to be submitted to the state.

Public input has made it very clear that no design which leads thousands of bikers (in season) to Route 6, with the attraction of downtown Wellfleet beckoning them past numerous perilous curbcuts can be seen as progress.

The TA’s upbeat report of “progress”based on public input” seems in deliberate disregard of public input.

When asked about this seeming discrepancy between his opinion and that of expressed public opinion on what constitutes progress on the rail trail, he replied that “There are a number of people in Town who have spoken to me and are in support of the extension of the Rail Trail” and “Because there are people both for and against the Rail Trail extension, I do not take a side and I do not represent either side.” But his declaration that continuing work on the extension constitutes progress would seem indeed to be taking sides, the side of an obvious minority against almost all expressed public opinion.

An email to members of the Select Board about the TA’s email elicited no response.

According to a member of the Bike and Walkways Committee, the Select Board has also been divided and ineffective in supporting the town meeting resolution and other expressed wishes of most citizens in negotiations with the state. When that committee asked the Select Board to sign a letter to Gov. Baker and state agencies supporting the town’s near unanimous town vote in town meeting, two members of the board stated their support for the state plan to bring the Rail Trail to Route 6 and voted against signing. Another wanted to wait and have the Select Board write its own letter, which has apparently not happened yet.

The TA in his email says “The Rail Trail extension is a project of the Mass. DCR, it is not a Town project,” and therefore, seems his implication, he or other agents of the town should basically butt out. But when the state experts came to town last year to pitch the idea of a roundabout in the same area of Route 6 they had the wisdom to withdraw that idea when they heard the resounding rejection of it on the part of locals, those most affected and with the most experience of the area.

Such an outcome should be possible here, but not without our town leaders–paid employees and elected reps–getting clear whose side they are on in this matter of great importance to our town.

Non-residents’ push for the vote: what’s at stake

Outer Cape non-resident taxpayers have clamored ever more loudly in recent years to be able to vote in the town where they own a house, as well as where they live. A recent My View by the president of the Provincetown Part-time Resident Taxpayers Association spells out the argument: to deny secondhome owners a say […]

Unfriendly discourse is not our problem

“Divisiveness” has become a major, much lamented theme in the time of Trump. The recent series in this paper decrying the lack of civil discourse encouraged the idea incivility is an issue itself, a style that can be separated from the substance of such problems as racism, immigration, mass murder, etc. That incivility is itself […]

Sharks vs. humans at play: Which side are we on?

I went swimming over the weekend at the same ocean beach in Wellfleet where the young man was killed by a shark last September. I had been thinking that, given the shark situation, I could eliminate ocean swimming from my recreation menu. But it was day two of the heat wave and the lowtide 2-4 […]

Confusion and clarity in the healthcare debate

Surely we can do better than the confusion which characterizes the 2020 election debate over whether or not such basics as healthcare or education should be treated as a human right. Should we have our government (of, by, and for the people, right?) run our healthcare system as it runs other key parts of our […]

Dem debate: swamped with virtuous candidates

There were so many qualified-seeming candidates on the two nights of the Democratic debate it was actually a relief to find one or two I didn’t find especially prepossessing. It was, to begin, a veritable orgy of diversity. Women candidates, “black” candidates,” brown” candidates, a candidate both female, black and the other sort of Indian.. […]

Local life marinating in tourism contradictions

A dramatic feature of life in a tourist destination is the shifting of gears on Memorial Day. Secondhome owners and other visitors sweep into town for a hit of their favorite vacation spot, light us up for a few days, and then retreat until the real season (by which time it is hoped we will […]

Wellfleet Rail Trail extension being railroaded by state

This time the state seems determined to have its way with the town of Wellfleet. In 2018 the state’s highway pros came to town to present a solution to our Route 6 troubles. There have been numerous accidents, including fatalities, and we had been casting about for a remedy. The state’s answer was the radical […]

Opposing cell phone antennas then and now

Mashpee and Centerville citizens’ cell phone antenna struggles are reminiscent of Wellfleet’s tilting at cell phone towers 20-plus years ago in the infancy of the industry. Up to several hundred determined Wellfleetians argued that microwaves beamed from cell towers were unhealthful, and that the gangly towers were in any case unsightly, and a contradiction of […]

Free college for all is simple democratic realism

A good thing to come out of the so-called “college admissions scandal” is recognition that it’s not a scandal at all, in the sense of especially shocking or outrageous. The wealthy using their money to get their kids into colleges that will enhance their chances of continuing the family tradition of being rich? It may […]