ELECTION REVEALS THE SORT OF COUNTRY WE ARE

Four and a half million votes is a substantial margin of victory. And yet it is also true to say that if over half the country is feeling great relief, roughly half the country not so much.

If it had been a landslide it would have been easier to believe that the last four years were, as a sign in a local anti-Trump celebration had it, “End of an Error.” An aberration. Not really us. As if the real America had just stood up (and looked kind of like Joe Biden).

The real America did stand up, of course, and the election provides a soberingly clear revelation of the sort of country we really are.

This is a country in which half of us experience Donald Trump not as the indecent, bragging, bullying, lying narcicist just all round nasty guy one half sees but as a good guy, their kind of guy, and more: a savior and great hero. The very same personal characteristics one half deplores delight the other half.

One half of us sees Obama as in the documentary currently showing on TV– “The Way I See It”–as a carismatic, eloquent, loving father and husband, so painfully all that Trump is not. And the other half apparently—somehow, bafflingly to our half, sees the same Obama as detestable and Trump all that the man he replaced is not.

There is a phenomenon called the “crater illusion”– you can see a moon crater as concave or convex, but not both at the same time. This would seem to fit perfectly how the two halves of the country see these two men.

This is a country in which half the citizens don’t hold it against Trump that his policies have probably killed over 100 thousand people who would not otherwise have died of the virus. (In a news story that appeared a couple of days ago, of the 300 hardest-hit counties in the country, 94% voted heavily for Trump.)

Roughly half of us would apparently prefer a country without journalism (and probably think the traditional media’s , including Fox News, reporting of the election’s outcome is “fake news”).

This is a country in which half the citizens are apparently perfectly comfortable with Trump”s failure to renew decades-old agreements with Russia protecting against the nuclear annihilation nightmare scenario of the Cold War.

Though a much higher percent are believers in human-made (and human-remediable) climate change, the half of us who voted for Trump presumably don’t care whether we do anything about that.

This is the sort of country, we learn by the election, for whom fascists and anti-fascists are morally equivalent. Who cheered when Trump told the Proud Boys “to stand by” with their guns. Who were tickled when a bus of Biden’s supporters was run off the road by Trump supporters near Austin, and Trump responded in a tweet, “I love Texas.” ,

Roughly half of us want to return to an America they presumably see as great, in which tens of millions of fellow citizens were without health care.

The roughly half the country who voted for Trump presumably get off on his playing fast and loose with basics of democracy, his documented attempts to suppress the vote, his hiring of a postmaster general who would help with that, his many attempts to cast doubt on the election process. It does not go too far to say that a vote for Trump was in fact a vote against democracy.

So while there is great relief for many at the ousting of Trump, it’s hard to ignore the other election result: evidence of what sort of country we are.

It’s a scary country.

Biden is passionate about the need for healing and it’s healing, at least for half the country, just to hear his appeal. Given what one half of us is like, wants, believes, there is a lot of healing to be done. It will probably take more than just deciding to take a more tolerant attitude toward each other.


SHORT TAKES On Our Current Situation

1/WHO GETS TO REPORT THE ELECTION RESULTS? Was there an actual difference in the network announcements (including Fox News) of Biden’s victory? Or was it just context that made me hear them differently, an awareness that for the first time this standard announcement was being made in the era of “fake news”? Trump has declared […]


MAGA versus voting the way forward

Nostalgia is a powerful emotion and MAGA—MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN– has been a powerful weapon for Trump and his forces. But of course it doesn’t hold up under more than two seconds’ scrutiny. Just when was that great America we want to go back to? That great period energized, for some anyway, by the pursuit […]


Expanding the Euro-centric “We”

“We” is changing. No, the grammar of that isn’t incorrect. What I mean is that the content of that pronoun –as in “we the people”– is changing. And this election is very much about that change. Columbus Day is still on the calendar. Most of us seem OK about the gift of an extra day […]


State still pushing dangerous Wellfleet Rail Trail extension

There’s good news and there’s bad news about the state’s controversial plan for Wellfleet’s bike path. The Department of Conservation and Recreation (DCR), has for several years been trying to sell the town on the idea of extending the Rail Trail, which since the 1980s has ended at Lecount Hollow Road in South Wellfleet, to […]


Looking for answers to questions about the situation we’re in

I read a fair amount of print media and listen to a lot of NPR news but I haven’t run across answers to the following questions, which seem like important ones. It may be that I’ve missed stories. Any ideas? > Why did Trump agree to let Woodward, well known liberal journalist, tape him? > […]


The election season of voting dangerously

You could almost thank Donald Trump for lessons about democracy. It’s almost as if he set out four years ago to expose our complacency and naivete and teach us about the vulnerability of our system to the impulses of one man of a certain sort. But that it would come to this, that only two […]


Homeschooling and the babysitting function of public education

One of the biggest effects of our response to the covid-19 virus is to turn us into a nation of involuntary homeschoolers. There’s always been a suspect coincidence between the educational and the babysitting functions of compulsory public education. Kids need to get educated as basic preparation for life and citizenship in a democracy. And […]


“ Queen of Katwe” and movies as cultural weapons

A s the debate about the tearing down of monuments and cancel culture in general has evolved, we’re beginning to see the problem with zero tolerance. If we are going to flush all the people and culture that are flawed with racism, anti-semitism, sexism and other sins, little or no culture would be left standing. […]


The end of the idea of police as peace-keepers

Whether or not policing is abolished, as has been seriously proposed, a cherished concept of policing has probably taken a mortal hit. The weeks since the nine minutes of a cop’s knee on George Floyd’s neck have made it much harder for anyone to seriously entertain the idea of policing as neutral peace-keeping. That’s the […]