The argument vs. pleasure

In the war against drug addiction, the strategy that gets the most press is taking the drug itself out of play, mostly through law enforcement. But until we succeed in ridding the world of such potent, life-wrecking pleasures, there should be more emphasis on learning to live in a world that has such temptations in it.

Pleasure is a powerful argument for itself. It is available in many forms: food, alcohol, sex, drugs, etc., all of which can and do give a lot of people trouble. The pleasure—the euphoria—of heroin is said to be extremely pleasureful, to the point of being irresistible.

In a world in which these strong pleasures are available, and the effects often so terrible, the question arises: how do you argue with pleasure? Especially early in life, when maximizing pleasure seems like the way to go, the response is likely (and reasonably enough) to be: How can you argue with pleasure? Why would you want to?

It’s a good guess that most of us know that survival to maturity depends precisely on on both asking the question and finding an answer to it. On getting beyond pleasure.

Simplifying a very complicated matter, what most of us discover if we live long enough, which most of us do, is that the satisfactions of a meaningful life (work, connection with others, problem solving, creativity broadly defined,) are deeper, stronger, more sustaining than the more obvious pleasures . Think of them as another category of pleasure.

Most of us know this; it is our sustaining wisdom. And yet you would not guess it from the prevailing “consumer society” description of us. You would not guess it from us or our life as depicted in TV ads.

In much of our most obvious and pervasive culture our ancient self-proclaimed right to pursue happiness looks a lot like pursuit of pleasure. Maybe that’s what the founders had in mind, but probably not.

It would seem that the TV advertising version of us and not our “beyond pleasure” survival wisdom, is what our president was taking us for when he inspired us at a moment of severe national crisis with the advice that the most useful, meaningful thing we could do was to “go shopping” (which is probably why that advice has been so widely ridiculed since almost the moment he uttered it).

If a larger portion of our youth are getting waylaid by drugs, it may have something to do with this pervasive culture of pleasure.

What is to be done? One thing is to get clear ourselves on our own “beyond pleasure” values. And then to build that wisdom and those values more consciously and effectively into education in our families and in the schools.

Will capitalism survive “The Big Short”?

Is everyone seeing “The Big Short,” now playing in local theaters? Everyone should be. We should all be thinking and talking about it. It’s a high energy tragi-comedy about about the hit-and-run of the 2008 housing collapse—and about the sort of work that tends to produce that sort of disaster. There are some movies which, […]

“Heroin: Cape Cod, USA”: an irony

One critical voice in the local discussion of the HBO documentary “Heroin: Cape Cod, U.S.A.” worries about the film’s possible impact on business. Won’t the influential expose of our heroin problem sully our pristine, bucolic image and cause people to think twice before vacationing and spending their tourist dollars here? At first that complaint seemed […]

Heroin: the epidemic and the void

The controversy around the HBO documentary “Heroin: Cape Cod, U.S.A.” seems to involve an unnecessary competition between two quite distinct issues. One: there is currently a crisis of addiction caused apparently by overprescription of painkillers and the availability of cheap heroin. Two: some people are much more susceptible to opioid addiction than others. Both are […]

Our transformation into a tourist town: some key questions

Wellfleet has had seasonal visitors since the late 19th century, but for many decades we were less tourist destination than a small town like most small towns, more here for ourselves than for outsiders. At some point that changed and our primary identification (and reality) began to be that of a tourist town. That crucial […]

HBO film on Cape opioid epidemic is not much help

One of the somber notes on which 2015 concluded was the airing on HBO of the documentary “Heroin: Cape Cod, U.S.A.” The film ends on an upbeat: one of the local addicts we’ve come to know in the film has been clean for three months and is hopeful about the future. But we have learned […]

The new Star Wars: a dissenting view.

There seems a conspiracy amongst reviewers to be kind to the new “Star Wars.” Is it out of nostalgia for the generation-and-a-half-old original, respect for an ancient icon? Who knows. In any case, I was unprepared by reviews for the movie. (Had I been properly prepared I wouldn’t have gone at all.) The movie feels […]

Taking Joy

The seasonal injunction to rejoice is always a tall order, even if you’re one of those lucky enough to be comfortable. It seems there are always more reasons, if you read the newspaper, to despair than to rejoice. In fact, given the shape the world is in, despair can seem the only reasonable—the only decent—attitude. […]


A month after the terrorist attacks on Paris, (and a few days after emails threatening schools systems of our two biggest cities) you would think that we would be working hard to understand this terrible and frightening phenomenon for the usual reasons we try to understand something bad: to keep it from happening to us […]

Email terrorism

On December 15th our two largest cities get emails threatening their school systems. New York decides it’s clearly an amateurish prank and does nothing about it. LA takes it seriously and cancels about 1000 schools. Most of a million kids stay home, confounding parental expectations, throwing how many workplaces off when at least some of […]