Crazy poor Americans

Can we talk about “Crazy Rich Asians”? We crazy, poor Americans are turning out in crazy numbers to see this movie, whose exotic opulence transcends its cliched romantic comedy plot.

The movie seems fresh, not just in its all-Asian cast, but in widening our continent-locked, monolinguistic diversity horizon. The plot takes us to Singapore, where we learn that Asians are– surprise!–not just smart, diligent immigrants wanting to crash our party but a whole other world with its own , even better party over there.

A big part of what’s entertaining about “Crazy Rich” is the display of wealth of a fabulously wealthy Asian family in a wedding set against the city of Singapore with its worldclass architectural skyline looking like the future. The shot or two of New York look positively drab by comparison.

So yes, all that is refreshing. And entertaining– sort of like the theatrics that accompanied the Beijing Olympics. And lord knows we need widening of our horizons. But what exactly are we to make (what does the movie want us to make) of the wild displays of wealth flaunted in virtually every scene?

The movie itself seems to waver in its perspective. It wants us to admire the Asia we only dimly knew existed: if you westerners think you have a corner on great capitalist wealth, think again. But pretty much the only thing it presents to admire about the far East is not traditional eastern ways, spiritual values, but wealth. Which at times, when viewed through the eyes of a couple of characters, can border on nauseating..

The hero’s dragon lady mother hints at traditional values the West knows nothing of. At one point she turns up her nose at an instance in the festivities that offends her. But it is her own traditional female sacrifice of personal ambition for the good of family that has produced this wealth and its excessive displays.

Is the great wealth a good thing or not.? Is it OK that a few can buy a half a billion dollar yacht for personal use, make a million dollar bequest to a pet toy poodle, stage a $30 million wedding?

In other words, is “obscene” wealth obscene or not? The movie seems conflicted and that’s part of what’s crazy.

For the most part, we relatively poor Americans, increasingly divided by economic inequality, are supposed to join in the fun and approve these displays of wealth and, by implication, the economic system that produces them. In this context be party-pooping to do otherwise, and audiences seem to be doing as expected. (Is it possible that some viewers see it as inspirational: If I work hard, I too….”)

The American Chinese woman who has won the love of the scion of the rich Asian family is not just beautiful. She is a professor of economics. As a former academic myself I kept wishing the movie would seriously put her academic values, a life spent doing something other than accumulating wealth, up against all this vulgar display. But it doesn’t happen. She insists that her rich guy love her for herself, has to fight off his rich ex-girlfriend, beats the dragon lady at her own game, but other than that, she seems as happily blown away by the festivities as anyone else. (Apparently in her academic life she’s not of the socialist persuasion.)

This movie and the major fuss we are making about it is not reassuring about the mess our own country is in, values-wise, in this stage of our history, as we are led (if that’s the word) by one of the very wealthy and his unerring capitalist values and instincts.

It would be flattering this movie to suggest that it’s about our confusion over great wealth. It embodies that confusion. And depends heavily on values cluelessnes on the part of lots of poor, crazy Americans.

Good for us; shame on us

You know that trick of eyesight: how you can see a moon crater as concave or as convex, but not both at the same time? It keeps flipping between. There was a story in this paper recently that produced for me something of the same effect. Back in the 80s and early 90s, Ben Buck, […]

Discriminating between two forms of democracy.

As an English major I’ve been confused by the term “populism” being bruited about recently. It has the sound of democracy, of which I have always been a fan. So why are so many liberals associating it with the drift toward fascism? Turning dutifully to my wikipedia, I discovered that the confusion is not just […]

Outer Cape non-residents pushing to vote locally

When Wellfleet’s non-resident taxpayers began to organize themselves about 20 years ago, they made a big point of declaring their innocence of any ambition for a vote in local affairs. But some, at least, of the growing demographic of second-home owners are now pushing for the vote. The Wellfleet Non-Resident Taxpayer Association (NRTA) recently held […]

Feelings complicate the immigration puzzle

Immigration has even a lot of liberals scratching their heads trying to figure out how we should feel about the various issues around the phenomenon of fellow human fleeing terrible conditions in other counties. The daunting complexity of the issues around the phenomenon of asylum-seekers just got a bit clearer with the outcry over the […]

The fight is on. Which side are you on?

Something’s wrong with our political system when the most unpopular and, in the opinion of most, morally dubious president ever will, via Supreme Court nominees, have one of the greatest influences on American life in coming decades. No doubt Trump idolators are chortling at the irony. Checks and balances? None of the three branches of […]

Roth: hetero guy and great writer

Philip Roth, who died on May 22 at 85, has long been castigated by feminists for sexism, but his case represents a twist on what has, in the MeToo, era become a familiar scenario. The careers of the likes of Morgan Freeman, Garrison Keillor, (or more seriously Bill Cosby) have been seriously damaged by their […]

Roseanne vs. “Roseanne”

Should “Roseanne” have been cancelled because Roseanne is a racist? The MeToo era, in which art is being removed from museums and TV shows cancelled because of the extracurricular behavior of the artists, raises the old question: How should we view the relationship between the art and the artist? Apparently ABC didn’t find “Roseanne” racist. […]


The death in March by an Uber self-driving prototype in Phoenix has been a serious speedbump on the road to what many think is the imminence of this revolutionary technology. The car’s braking system was apparently mis-programmed and the human overseer possibly distracted. In media stories, all the emphasis has been on the unacceptability of […]

What is causing “Deaths of Despair”?

“Deaths of despair on the rise across state, country” read the headline of a recent story in this paper. Massachusetts is only 34th in the nation in deaths from suicide, alcohol, and drugs, as such deaths are being defined. But the Cape’s suicide rate is twice that of the state, the story noted. Given that […]