Roth: hetero guy and great writer

Philip Roth, who died on May 22 at 85, has long been castigated by feminists for sexism, but his case represents a twist on what has, in the MeToo, era become a familiar scenario. The careers of the likes of Morgan Freeman, Garrison Keillor, (or more seriously Bill Cosby) have been seriously damaged by their alleged hurtful behavior toward women. Their art itself is widely considered blameless, worthy of its reputation, but is being suppressed in some cases because of its association with the artists.

On the other hand it is Roth’s writing itself–often celebrated as Nobel Prize-worthy, even if he never actually got it–that numerous women have objected to. The question is: should Roth the man be tainted by association with the badboy behavior of his male characters?

Like most writers considered “great”, an adjective used in most obituaries, Roth was tremendously ambitious, telling compelling stories about many of the most important themes of our time: anti-semitism and fascism of the 1930s and 40s, radicalism of the 1960s, racism. But certainly one of the subjects most associated with Roth is the sexual life of men. It is his depiction of this part of life that has gotten him the label, in some quarters, of a sexist for whom women function mostly as sex objects. Roth, according to one critic, “is never inside the heads of his females. . .” (Ellen Sofie Lauritzen in TPM, March 2015)

Roth frequently insisted in interviews, this is fiction, these are imagined characters. Don’t confuse the author with his creations. And any sophisticated view of the art form would agree. But the fact is that you can’t read Roth without getting the sense that the plight of his male characters (often men of Roth’s age, sometimes writers) has a lot in common with that of their author. Yes, they are imagined characters, but Roth (like most men) clearly knows and appreciates that male, hetero terrain well from personal experience. Imagination doesn’t work in a vacuum.

(The actress Claire Bloom wrote a very unflattering review of her marriage to Roth, but that’s another matter.)

Great art is often defined by its transcendent universality. But nothing in Roth’s prolific life’s work suggests that he was less stuck in his biological gender than most men.

In an early novella, “The Breast,” Roth has his character Kepesh wake up one day to find himself being transformed into a giant female breast. Thus does Roth use imagination of this Kafkaesque grotesquerie as a way, it would seem, of transcending the typical male fetish. But in fact the whole story is written from the energy of that fetish. As the female critic quoted above says, he doesn’t seem interested in that story in being “inside the head” of an actual woman on the subject of that body part that so energizes most men. And there is no relief for Kepesh: even when he actually becomes the fetish he continues to lust after it.

So when it comes to gender, if he’s in the same boat as most men, wherein lies Roth’s greatness? Not in transcending his gender but in bringing to bear on a situation he and his characters share his compelling and inimitable voice, humor, irony, intelligence; his humanity, if thoroughly a male version.

I suppose, from a woman’s point of view, that might be seen as giving aid and comfort to the enemy.

No, Roth is not universal , but it’s an interesting question whether there are any writers, male or female, capable ot genuine transcendence of their gender.

I recommend his books of male aging, written in his 70s in an amazing late outpouring, as good company for aging men–and women too, insofar as they are interested in getting inside the heads of aging men

Roseanne vs. “Roseanne”

Should “Roseanne” have been cancelled because Roseanne is a racist? The MeToo era, in which art is being removed from museums and TV shows cancelled because of the extracurricular behavior of the artists, raises the old question: How should we view the relationship between the art and the artist? Apparently ABC didn’t find “Roseanne” racist. […]


The death in March by an Uber self-driving prototype in Phoenix has been a serious speedbump on the road to what many think is the imminence of this revolutionary technology. The car’s braking system was apparently mis-programmed and the human overseer possibly distracted. In media stories, all the emphasis has been on the unacceptability of […]

What is causing “Deaths of Despair”?

“Deaths of despair on the rise across state, country” read the headline of a recent story in this paper. Massachusetts is only 34th in the nation in deaths from suicide, alcohol, and drugs, as such deaths are being defined. But the Cape’s suicide rate is twice that of the state, the story noted. Given that […]

Are we dying? Or just changing?

In Wellfleet’s recent town meeting a speaker noted, as shocking evidence of the need for affordable housing, that “in last 25 years we have lost 62% of the young people in our town.” In a column a couple of years ago I raised the question “are Outer Cape towns dying?” I had seen an article […]

Does Facebook have more to apologize for than electricity or the telephone?

I’m sure there must be an easy answer to the following question that occurs to this pre-millennial. In Mark Zuckerberg’s recent appearance before a congressional committee, Rep. David McKinley, a West Virginia Republican, pointed to Facebook ads offering opioids for sale without a prescription and addressed Zuckerberg accusingly: “Facebook is actually enabling an illegal activity, […]

Thoreau: liberal or conservative?

173 years ago this March, Henry David Thoreau, age 28, took his axe down to the still chilly shore of Walden Pond and began cutting down pine trees with which to frame his famous cabin. It was an iconic American moment, embodying youth, hope, can-do spirit. It’s my favorite part of “Walden,” the perennial classic […]

Taking the future into their own hands

On March 14th students around the country will leave school to protest the latest school massacre, at the Parkland Florida high school, and all the others. Teachers and administrators are being invited to walk out, too. But the students apparently aren’t asking permission to do this.If this shows disrespect for their elders, so be it. […]

On failing to understand bitcoins

I admit it, I’m confused about bitcoins. Actually, now that I think about it, my failure to comprehend what is for me aptly called “cryptocurrency” is only the latest in a lifelong history of failure to understand technology. I’ve driven a car since I was 16, and I still don’t really understand that either. I […]

Queen Elizabeth for president?

I just finished watching the second season of “The Crown,” the Netflix series about the career of the current Queen Elizabeth. Given the timing, I doubt the series was conceived in response to the American crisis of leadership. But in a year in which the overarching headline has been “country coming apart at the seams,” […]